Score: 5

Arielle Nissenblatt • EarBuds Podcast Collective • Jun 10, 2022

"Phoebe Judge is a haltingly brilliant speaker and storyteller. It’s clear that her voice takes on the weight of this story as she goes through the events of the day as Roselle and Michael experienced them. "

See Full Review

Score: 5

Elena Nicolaou • Refinery29 • Dec 21, 2018

"This Is Love is the warm, story-based podcast to listen to when the news is too much to bear. You'll feel instantly pulled into the subjects' lives, and loves."

See Full Review

Score: 5

Eliana Dockterman • Time • Jun 5, 2018

"Judge excels at finding interesting subjects with fascinating stories. These ones just happen to be more uplifting (and a bit less voyeuristic) than those in Criminal. But they are equally as surprising."

See Full Review

Score: 4.9

ETonline Staff • Entertainment Tonight • Feb 19, 2018

"The end result is certainly not expected, but it is an intriguing must-listen."

See Full Review

Score: 5

Miranda Sawyer • The Guardian • Feb 18, 2018

"...beautifully paced, with memorable details...it’s a gorgeous listen."

See Full Review

Score: 5

Carly Mallenbaum • USA Today • Feb 13, 2018

"Like Criminal, This Is Love is a careful combination of interviews, music and Judge's narration that makes for a seamless and satisfying listening experience. But the new show has a different tone: It's warmer."

See Full Review