Score: 5

Fiona Sturges • Financial Times • Feb 16, 2025

"Two episodes in, Why Is Amy in the Bath? has echoes of Dead Eyes, a similarly entertaining podcast which also asks an odd question...Reynolds and Lombardo use their theme as a springboard to uncover the history, thought processes and tropes of the film industry. And so a seemingly absurd question about an actor’s career choices quickly turns into something else: a funny, quizzical and improbably in-depth podcast about the nature of success itself."

See Full Review