Sample Clip

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark

Publisher: Exactly Right

Critic Rating: 4.8/5


Lifelong fans of true crime stories Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark tell each other their favorite tales of murder and hear hometown crime stories from friends and fans.

Critic Reviews

Score: 4.5

Jordan Burgmeier - Creightonian - Sep 10, 2020

"The hosts feel relatable, and although they can get carried away in unrelated conversation, they are fantastic storytellers. If you want a way to learn more about crime and not feel overwhelmed with forensics and gory details, “My Favorite Murder” is worth listening to."

See Full Review

Score: 5

Rebecca Lavoie - Vulture - Oct 1, 2019

"It’s at once earnest and silly, irreverent and crusading, and can take credit for building an unrivaled fan community that extends far beyond the podcast itself."

See Full Review

More In True Crime

The Doodler

Neon Hum Media, SF Chronicle, Ugly Duckling Films

Score: 4.5

Go to Podcast


True Crime with Suruthi & Hannah

Score: 5.0

Go to Podcast

Finding Natasha

Message Heard

Score: 4.5

Go to Podcast


Serial, This American Life

Score: 4.7

Go to Podcast